This one has sodium chloride in it. I’m sure it’s there as a cheap thickener and may be just fine, but I’m paranoid. I don’t like to use a conditioner with salt in it because I leave the conditioner in my hair, and salt is corrosive. I’m not thrilled with it in shampoos either. But since it’s rinsed out in shampoos, I’m okay/ eh using products with it in there. But in a conditioner, it is not okay. Conditioners should be healthy and soothing for the hair, and I don’t feel that salt is soothing.